This blog puts a spotlight on the working class in the U.S. South, always in context with what is going on nationally and internationally in the Global South as well. This blog provides a historical and cultural--including music, literature, film, and art--perspective about the region with a special focus on the long, hard, and often bloody struggle Southern workers have always had in asserting their rights, particularly whenever they tried to organize.
It has been a busy week for yours truly. Ed “Flash” Ferenc
of WERE-AM 1490 in Cleveland, Ohio, interviewed me Wednesday, Sept. 25, about
the United Auto Workers campaign at the Nissan plant in Canton, Miss. WERE-AM
is “The People’s Station”, a radio station devoted to talking about labor issues
and telling the stories of working class people, and it’s living proof that
corporate media haven’t quite yet shut down the discussion on those stories or
on labor issues in general.
On Ferenc’s “America’s Work Force” show, we discussed the
labor movement in the South, its obstacles, how the image of the union-hostile,
low-wage, low-benefits, environmentally lax South lamentably has become a model
for the rest of the nation. The UAW’s success at the Volkswagen plant in
Chattanooga, Tenn., also came up. The union says it has enough signed cards
from workers for a German-style works council to be set up at the plant. Check
out the show at: http://awfradio.com/todays-show-9-25-13/
The UAW’s turn to the South is also the subject of a lengthy
piece I just completed for upcoming edition of the New Labor Forum in New York. The NLF is arguably the finest journal
devoted to labor issues in the country today, and I was proud to write for
them.
The South indeed is again a battleground, and the outcome
will affect the entire nation. Workers need a united voice. That’s the only way
to counter the Republican-backed corporate juggernaut. I shouldn’t let
Democrats off the hook here. A lot of them spend too much time acting like
Republicans. Working people have to look past party lines to see who their real
friends are.
Teachers are protesting in North Carolina. They ought to
protest. They’re the lowest-paid teachers in the nation, according to one recent report.
Fast food workers have had it with sub-minimum wages and disrespect at the
workplace. Auto workers get better pay than most folks in the South wearing
a blue collar these days, but they know it isn’t only about the pay. It’s about
respect. The United Auto Workers and other unions realize that, and it’s why
their message is getting heard in Dixie. Let it ring loud and clear!
(The following feature column by yours truly appeared in a recent edition of the Jackson Free Press in Jackson, Miss. For this reason, please cite the Jackson Free Press when publishing this elsewhere.)
OXFORD, Miss. –
The great journalist, raconteur, and connoisseur of good food A.J. Liebling loved
to venture off the beaten tracks of New York and Paris to find little restaurants
and bistros overlooked by the culinary critics and trend-setters but where a man
with a taste for good dining could enjoy himself.
Liebling knew
such places—“lost Atlantises” he called them--often have a precarious
existence. “The small restaurant is evanescent,” he writes in his 1959 classic Between Meals. “Sometimes it has the
life span of a man, sometimes of a fruit fly.”
A more recent
writer, the former chef and current TV food and travel personality Anthony
Bourdain, had this to say about the perils of the restaurant business in his
own book Kitchen Confidential: “To
want to open a restaurant can be a strange and terrible affliction. What causes
such a destructive urge in so many otherwise sensible people? Why would anyone
want to pump their hard-earned cash down a hole that statistically, at least,
will almost surely prove dry?”
Maher Alqasas,
50, a native of the Mount of Olives in Palestine and longtime resident and
veteran restaurant owner here in Oxford, acknowledges the risks. “This is a
tough business. Imagine working 12 hours a day and having a smile on your face
for 12 hours, and to like what you do. The kitchen is a fireball, booming,
loud, and I have to be a part of that. What makes it worth it at the end of the
day in seeing the smile on their faces.”
He’s talking
about the smile on the faces of customers at his Middle Eastern-Mediterranean
restaurant Petra Cafe, open since February, a long, narrow stretch of a place
in the corner of the town’s famous Square that once housed Wiley’s shoe shop
and later Parrish’s bar. “Food is the moment of celebration,” says Alqasas, who
grew up in Qatar, “because when you are hungry you are willing to eat anything,
but if you know you are eating something good, it is a joy. You are nourishing
your body.”
The food at
Petra--falafel, kibbeh, hummus, labneh, dolmas, chicken shawerma, shish kabob,
gyros with tiziki sauce—isn’t exactly what you’d find on the tables of most
Southern homes. But it’s just as homemade and just as likely from old family
recipes, says Petra chef and Alqasas’ wife, Angela, also a native of Palestine.
“My customers come to my kitchen and tell me it’s the best falafel they’ve ever
had, customers from Chicago, Michigan,” she says with pride. “I love it. I
remember when I was a kid, my mom asked me to do the falafel. We used to help my
mom. I learned from my mother and my mother-in-law.”
The Alqasas—their
three children work at Petra, too--like the idea of a homey atmosphere, even
though home for them would be exotic to most Oxonians. The walls feature
paintings of street scenes and merchants from Old Egypt. The music is Turkish,
the carpet at the front door is Persian. “I’m trying to keep the Oxford look,
too, the old and new,” Maher Alqasas says. “This is an old building (a century
old, he estimates) but with fresh legs … new ceiling, new floor, new electrical,
new everything.”
Still, running a
successful restaurant on Oxford’s Square can require more than good food and
good atmosphere. Most of the two dozen or more restaurants and bars on or near
the Square also serve alcohol. They’re why the town’s thriving night life rivals
that of much larger cities. Petra allows brown-bagging but serves no alcohol.
Does it hurt
business? “It does,” Alqasas admits, “but eventually it is going to be known. Customers
can bring their own. It is worth the wait. It is all about the food.”
Alqasas is
Muslim. His religious faith is one reason he wants to avoid serving alcohol.
Another is the bar he once had in an earlier version of Petra a few blocks
away. “It made my life miserable as far as inventory, keeping kids working, no
stealing. … I don’t want to be a part of it.”
At least some of
his customers don’t mind. “It didn’t stop us,” said Ole Miss student Shelby
Herring, a 21-year-old hospitality management major from Houston, Texas, during
a recent meal there with her friend and fellow Ole Miss student Molly Thrush.
“I like Mediterranean food. I’m a vegetarian, so I like the falafel (fried
ground vegetables), the salads, the hummus. Back home, I’d go once a week to a
Middle Eastern or Mediterranean restaurant.”
Restaurants typically
take a couple years to turn a decent profit. Petra just suffered through the summer
doldrums that tend to hurt the bottom lines of most college town businesses.
Many tables remained empty during the summer evenings.
“I am a patient
person,” Alqasas says. However, he admits, he was more than ready for the fall
invasion of Ole Miss students.
In this latest roundup.
Labor South looks at calls for a new “Operation Dixie”, GOP-appointed
“Czars” in Democratic strongholds, and striking fast-food workers.
Calls for a modern-day
“Operation Dixie”
Delegates at the 2013 convention of the AFL-CIO in Los
Angeles this week adopted a a resolution proposed by the Savannah (Ga.)
Regional Central Council “to develop a Southern organizing strategy” as “one of
its top priorities” and one that will “include a long-term commitment to
organize the South.”
Resolution 26 decries the fact that the U.S. labor movement
“has never successfully developed a concerted and coordinated effort to
organize workers in the 11 Southern states” of the Southern Region, thus
“allowing the most conservative political forces in the South to operate
without effectively being challenged by organized workers.”
The South today is “a major player in the new global
economy,” the resolution says, “and has become a haven for US manufacturing,
foreign investments and finance capital, and because of this reemergence is now
playing an integral role in shaping US labor and social policies.”
Yet “corporations in the South have not only exploited
Southern workers but have also been responsible for the negative environmental
impact on many working class families, especially the African American, Latino,
Native American, Asian and poor white communities.”
Conservative Southern politicians have okayed “billions of
dollars in tax breaks and incentives” to corporations “at the expense of these
struggling communities.”
Even as convention delegates adopted this resolution,
however, much work is already underway to, indeed, organize the South, an
effort tracked closely by Labor South.
The United Auto Workers, in a do-or-die effort to rebuild,
is actively working with the IG Metall union in Germany and even some company
officials to establish German-style works councils at the Volkswagen plant in
Chattanooga, Tenn., and the Mercedes-Benz plant in Vance, Ala. Despite
opposition from political leaders in both states, VW officials are talking with
union leaders about the move, and Mercedes-Benz officials say they’re neutral
to the idea.
In fact, in a major breakthrough, Gary Casteel, UAW regional director for the South, said this week that a majority of workers at the VW plant in Chattanooga have now signed cards supporting a works council. Casteel told Associated Press that the cards are the legal equivalent of an actual election. He declined to say when the union would seek formal recognition.
Besides its work at the German plants, the UAW has helped build a wide-ranging
grassroots campaign over the past eight years to organize the 5,200 workers at
the Nissan plant in Canton, Miss. That campaign has taken activists around the
country and as far away as Brazil and South Africa to make the case for a union
vote in Canton. Hundreds now attend union-related events, even as Mississippi
Gov. Phil Bryant and other state leaders lock arms in opposition. Bryant
attacked a recent study showing Nissan will receive up to $1.33 billion in
government incentives over a 30-year period despite never living up to all the
promises that came with its arrival in Mississippi. To counteract the UAW, Nissan
has waged a high-stakes campaign to endear itself to the area black
community—an estimated 80 percent of the workforce at the plant is
black—offering hundreds of thousands of dollars in grants to local schools and
civil rights organizations.
Even back in 1946, when the original “Operation Dixie” was
launched, labor leaders recognized the crucial importance of the South to
labor’s future, the potential for Southern-bred anti-unionism to spread to the
rest of the country. The campaign ended in failure in the early 1950s, but the
predictions that prompted it have proven true. The South has to be organized,
or the U.S. labor movement will eventually shrink into nonexistence.
Who needs democracy?
Let’s appoint a “Czar”!
Detroit’s fiscal woes are widely known, and the Republican
version of what caused them is the familiar tirade against a government-run-amuck
with fat pensions and greedy unions at the heart of the problem. Michigan’s
Republican governor, Rick Snyder, and the financial manager, Kevyn Orr, he
chose to rule over the bankrupt city have targeted pension plans in their plan
to restore fiscal integrity.
The plan fails to take into account the myriad reasons why
Detroit got into such trouble, including NAFTA and other trade deals that put U.S.
workers at a disadvantage (Michigan lost more jobs to NAFTA than any other
state). Like Republican pols in the South, Michigan’s “fiscal conservative”
pols aren’t above spending taxpayer money for causes they do support, such as
$283 million for a pro-hockey stadium.
Oh, and by the way, Orr refused requests by the AFSCME to
meet despite promises that union leaders would be part of the discussion about
Detroit’s future.
When Tennessee State Comptroller Justin Wilson issued a
warning to the city of Memphis this spring regarding its finances, local media
and other observers wondered, “Is Memphis the next Detroit?”
Wilson told Memphis that its future depended on city leaders
getting their fiscal act together in fixing the city’s ailing $622 million operating
budget. Memphis has long been a Democratic stronghold in a very Republican
state. Local economists insist Memphis is a long way from a Detroit-style state
takeover, but how much will pension holders and other regular folks in Memphis have
to suffer to keep that from happening?
Eerily similar to these developments is a recent decision by
the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges (ACCJC) in
California to take away San Francisco City College’s accreditation by the
summer of 2014 if it fails to implement a multi-part plan that critics say
essentially moves the school toward privatization.
San Francisco City College has been a democratic haven—known
for shared governance, strong unions, and local activism—for years, and thus a
burr in the saddle of conservative Republicans and even some Democrats.
Fast-food workers
tired of working for less than living wages
The nationwide strikes and worker actions against low wages
in the fast-food industry had spread to the South by the end of August, according to the North
Carolina-based Institute for Southern Studies’ Facing South online magazine.
Fast-food workers in at least 11 Southern cities joined
the nationwide strike, including workers in the Triangle region of North
Carolina. North Carolina is perennially the nation’s least-unionized state.
Workers struck in Charlotte, Raleigh, Durham,
Greensboro, Atlanta, Houston, Austin, Dallas, Memphis, New Orleans and Gretna,
La.
The workers are seeking an hourly pay of $15. Their current
average pay nationwide is $8.94 an hour.
This is a $200 billion industry. McDonald’s last year posted
profits of $5.47 billion.
Labor South is still on the watch although other writing duties have kept yours truly from posting recently.
Coming soon will be a look at a potential trend among conservative state political leaders to take over local entities that don't fit their preferred political profile.
We've seen this already with the state takeover of the city of Detroit, a city that granted has a lot of problems but which as a Democratic stronghold also makes a mighty juicy target for Republican pols. A recent warning from state officials in Tennessee that city leaders in Memphis better get their fiscal house in order raised concerns that Memphis could be another Detroit--another inviting target, that is.
More recently, students at City College of San Francisco have protested the possible loss of accreditation and shutdown of the school, popular for its low tuition and strong network of campus and community activists. CCSF has an active teachers' union and a tradition of shared and democratic leadership. It has also been under attack by the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges. The state community colleges chancellor has designated a "czar" to oversee campus operations. These political entities question the college's budget decision-making, among other things.
Of course, another growing issue is the spreading protest by fast-food workers about their wages, a protest that has included several Southern cities.
The central theme of this short Labor South round-up could be hypocrisy.
What would Martin
Luther King Jr. and Medgar Evers say?
At the recent 50th anniversary commemoration of
the 1963 March on Washington, the NAACP joined hands with the Nissan
Corporation in welcoming tens of thousands of participants.
“This event is a celebration of diversity, community and
inclusion,” said Rob Wilson, director of diversity and inclusion at Nissan, in
a press release about the Nissan-NAACP partnership at the event. “We live by these values every day at Nissan, and our success
demonstrates what a talented and diverse workforce can accomplish.”
Of course, what the August 23 press release doesn’t say is this: If civil
rights leaders Martin Luther King Jr. and Medgar Evers were alive today, they’d
be fighting Nissan’s strong anti-union stand at its plants in Canton, Miss.,
and Smyrna, Tenn., tooth and nail. In his last years, King made economic and
workers rights the core of his mission for true equality in the United States. He died after standing in solidarity with the striking sanitation
workers in Memphis.
Evers worked closely with Mississippi AFL-CIO leaders Claude
Ramsay and Ray Smithhart during the Mississippi movement in the early 1960s,
and they all worked hard both for civil and worker rights.
As proof of Nissan's support for the NAACP's mission and King's vision in 1963, the press release said the company “and its generous employees” have
contributed more than $8 million to 100 Black Men, Habitat for Humanity, United
Way and other organizations since 2003. What it hasn’t done, of course, is raise wages for
its Canton workers in years, and what it’s not likely to ever do is willingly
accepted a union for its Southern workers.
A $100,000
gift by Nissan to the Medgar and Myrlie Evers Institute earlier this year is believed to have been a factor in the absence of actor-labor activist
Danny Glover on the rostrum at the subsequent annual Medgar Evers
dinner in Jackson, Miss. Glover was expected to speak.
Walmart once more
wants to “buy American”
You got to give it credit. The Arkansas-based retail monster
Walmart has audacity. At its two-day “Walmart U.S. Manufacturing Summit” in
Orlando, Fla., this month, the company reiterated an earlier promise to buy $50
billion more in U.S.-made products during the next 10 years. Other companies
should also increase their purchase of U.S. goods, Walmart officials said as
they pushed for a “made-in-America” movement.
On hand to applaud the challenge were U.S. Commerce
Secretary Penny Pritzker, eight governors (including Mississippi’s Phil Bryant),
hundreds of manufacturers, and many more.
Bear in mind, this $50 billion pledge by Walmart accounts
for just 10 percent of its projected retail sales for this year alone. Big
whooping deal!
Walmart has done this before. As reported recently in this
blog, the company preached “Buy America” 30 years ago then proceeded to turn to
foreign countries for 80 percent of its suppliers. More recently, it has found
itself in hot water—at least publicity-wise--for the horrible working and
safety conditions in the factories of some of those suppliers, conditions believed to have contributed to hundreds of tragic deaths.
Rising wages in China and Cambodia have made U.S.
corporations like Walmart look elsewhere for the cheaply made products they
put on their shelves. In the meantime, however, why not sound a patriotic note
and talk “Buy America” again? Besides, wages are down in the United States, and
this new “Made in America” campaign may make good business sense.
Of course, Walmart has played as large a role as any other
corporation in helping keep the wages of blue-collar workers in the United
States flat despite their increased productivity. Wages “for the entire bottom 60 percent of the
wage distribution” of earners “were flat or declined” between 2000 and 2012, write
Lawrence Mishel and Heidi Shierholz in their August briefing paper on a recent report by the Economic Policy Institute. This is despite a nearly 25 percent increase in productivity over the
same period.
(Writer George Orwell's passport picture when he was in Burma in the 1920s)
Walmart publicly preached “Buy America” three decades ago,
and the Arkansas-based retail giant imported less than 6 percent of the
products it sold in the United States. By 2006 four-fifths of its suppliers
were based in China.
Then China’s workers began protesting their conditions and
eventually got the attention of the Communist Party leadership in Beijing,
which feared rising worker militancy in the workers’ paradise. Over the past 10
years, blue-collar workers’ wages have risen some 400 percent.
So like other U.S.-based corporate bottom-feeders, Walmart
looked beyond China for suppliers that could meet Walmart’s stringent cost
demands through low wages and poor working conditions. They found their new
partners in Bangladesh, home of the world’s lowest wages. The cost of those
minimal conditions became clear last November with the Tazreen garment factory
fire near Dhaka that killed 112 workers and again, even more so, in the Rana
Plaza factory collapse in April that killed 1,129 workers.
A result of those tragedies has been a global spotlight on
the U.S. companies fed low-priced products by suppliers in Bangladesh that
could care less about safety conditions or workers’ livelihood. Even as major
European companies responded by agreeing to a new, legally binding accord requiring
independent inspections of supplier factories, Walmart, J.C. Penney, Sear’s,
Macy’s, Target, Gap, and other U.S. firms resisted. American greed countenances
little or nothing that stands in the way of its insatiable appetite. And
neither do its defenders in Washington.
Expect Walmart and Co. to be looking even farther beyond China and beyond Bangladesh now
in the “race to the bottom.” Cambodia has already been a beneficiary, but now
workers are protesting there, too, and wages are rising. The New York Times recently reported that
industrial wages in Cambodia have grown 65 percent in the last five years.
“The race to the bottom has hurt workers all over the
world,” Hong Kong’s top independent labor leader and Labour Party chair Lee
Cheuk-yan told me during an interview in Hong Kong in June. “The ability of
capital of moving to the cheapest labor is very efficient from their point of
view, but from our point of view it is a race to the bottom. Even Chinese labor
now is seen as too expensive, and they are moving to Bangladesh, Cambodia.
Myanmar will be next. When will it end? The ability of capital to move around
so easily is hurting workers everywhere.”
Myanmar, also known as Burma, indeed will be next. With military rule in
that long-tortured country now allowing greater democracy and
outside investment to aide its disastrous economy, the corporate bottom-feeders are licking their chops. "Foreign governments and multinationals have converged on a country that occupies a unique geostrategic position between the new Asian superpowers of India to the west and China to the east," said The Economist in a special report in May. "Private companies are jostling to capture a share of an almost virginal consumer market of some 60 (million) people" - and, let us not forget, cheap, really cheap, workers.
Workers at the Japanese-owned Famoso garment factory in Yangon earn the equivalent of $100 a month, "a quarter of the going rate in China," The Economist reports. "The mix of low wages, a plentiful supply of labour and access to American and European markets should mean that many more Famosos will be set up in Myanmar."
Walmart probably doesn’t yet have an image problem in Yangon
(Myanmar’s capital, once known as Rangoon). Not like it does here in the United
States.
Back in May the retailer agreed to pay $82 million in fines
after admitting guilt in the improper dumping of hazardous wastes in Missouri
and California.Walmart workers and
warehouse workers for Walmart suppliers have staged walkouts and strikes in
recent months to protest the litany of worker abuses that have made Sam
Walton’s corporate creation infamous.
Adding insult to injury, the District of Columbia Council in
Washington passed a “living wage” bill that would require Walmart to pay its
employees a minimum of $12.50 an hour if the retailer opens the six stores it
has planned there. Walmart was aghast, of course.
Can you blame the city’s leaders? Remember this
multi-billion-dollar company has been so chintzy with its workers that 46
percent of their children had no health insurance or were dependent on Medicaid
in 2006. A congressional report at the time showed that each Walmart store
generated an average $420,750 in Medicaid, Food Stamps, and public housing
costs to taxpayers.
Don’t know whether members of the Walton family--or other corporate leaders--are reading
George Orwell’s Burmese Days (a book about Britain's colonial rule of that country) to
prepare for their next adventure, but
folks in Yangon better get ready. The corporate colonialists and imperialists are
planning a major comeback.
“We are different from other generations,” says the
19-year-old English major at nearby Tougaloo College. “We have such an
individualistic ideal, how we see things. We have to get away from that and see
other people’s problems.… If we took
our eyes off that narrow path and look at the person next to us, we could
unify.”
Her cause? Doing everything she can to get the 5,000-plus
workers at the Nissan plant in Canton membership cards with the United Auto
Workers. “To be able to voice their opinions and their needs without being
worried they are going to get fired. … (to) have the grounds to talk to someone
about safety issues, health care benefits, temp workers, what happens to them
if they get injured.”
I’m sitting across the table from Mohamed and fellow
Tougaloo student Kimar Cain at the UAW office on Nissan Parkway, and I’m
remembering my student days back in the ‘60s, protesting for civil rights and
against the Vietnam War. Young people need a cause. They’ve got the energy, the
courage, the idealism that tells them they can make a difference.
(To the right is Kimar Cain)
And they can.
Young people are a key reason things are happening on the UAW-Nissan
front. The call from workers and community supporters for a fair union election
at the Canton plant is getting louder.
The 150-plus members of the Mississippi Student Justice
Alliance from Tougaloo and Jackson State University in Jackson, joined by
supporters from other colleges in Georgia, Florida and Tennessee, are taking
the issue into neighborhoods, car dealerships, auto shows, on-campus rallies,
the Internet and YouTube.
They are part of a larger campaign that has seen Nissan-Canton
workers speak to audiences in Brazil, Japan and South Africa as well as in U.S.
cities such as Washington, D.C., Atlanta and Detroit. Brazilian labor leaders
and students have come to Canton to show their support and study what veteran
observers see as potentially the most important labor campaign in decades.
“We have a lot of talent on this team,” says Cain, a 23-year-old
senior at Tougaloo majoring in history and African-American Studies. “From
writers to videographers to photographers. Everything visual and that can be
heard, we have those things, and we have the ability to get it out, and get it
out quickly and let it be seen so people can really dig into what we are saying,
and they’re like … `How can I get involved?’ ”
I can’t help but reminisce. What was missing back in my day
was a real alliance with working-class people. Students were out there
protesting in the 1960s, but few blue-collar workers joined them. Most were
even hostile.
(Jeffrey Moore)
This cause is dramatically different. Students are on the frontlines
side-by-side with workers, and the workers appreciate it. “I am very proud” of
the students, says Jeffrey Moore, 35, an 11-year veteran Nissan employee. “They
are doing something out of their time. You’ll never get a lot of play on that
out of the media. They are doing a lot of hard work for us, trying to make this
thing go down.”
They’re getting Nissan’s attention, too.
After a history of mixed relations with local political
leaders who’ve been prohibited from annexing the plant and who’ve had little
input into its expansion plans, Nissan’s bosses “all of a sudden are pillars of
the community,” Moore says.
In recent months, Nissan announced a $500,000 education
grant to Canton schools and a $100,000 gift to the Medgar and Myrlie Evers
Institute, hosted a 10-year anniversary free festival featuring the R&B
group Kool & the Gang, promised a pay raise to workers (after a seven-year
hiatus since the last pay raise), and a new program to help temporary workers
transition into fulltime workers.
Nissan’s $100,000 gift to the Evers Institute is a key
reason, sources believe, why Hollywood celebrity Danny Glover, a vocal and
active supporter of unionization at the Canton plant, did not speak at the annual
Medgar Evers dinner last month even though he had been a speaker in the past
and was expected to speak again this year.
(To the right is Anthony Wayne Walker)
“The barbarians are at the gates,” says Anthony Wayne
Walker, 39, a metal finisher at Nissan’s Canton plant and union supporter. “You
got to give them something to eat. It is one thing the corporation doesn’t
like. It is bad publicity. That equates to sales, to dollar signs, so you
counteract everything the union is doing. Throw ‘em a bone, and it looks good
on TV. All of a sudden you come out with a checkbook.”
Of course, leading the applause for Nissan are Mississippi
Gov. Phil Bryant and the state’s other top pols, despite a recent report
showing the state’s record $1.3 billion investment in Nissan has failed to reap
the promised rewards and resulted in a $290,000 subsidy for each Nissan-Canton
job.
Nissan worker Walker says he knows why, and a question to
Gov. Bryant would explain it to the rest of us: “Who are you playing golf with?”